November 28, 2009

A very bling bling kiss

Court of Appeals, Nîmes, June 2, 2009

Latest rebound in the “kiss” affair : playing the role of the rejected lover, in this case dismissed, Rindy Sam is ordered to pay the amount of 18,840 € to the Yvon Lambert gallery, and 1000 € in costs under article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or the penalty initially requested against her in the first trial court for having put her red lipsticked lips on the immaculate canvas of Cy Twombly during a temporary exposition of Gallery Lambert in Avignon in 2007.

The judges in the first trial court proceeding were unmoved by the young lady’s arguments that it was a spontaneous gesture of love motivated by the admiration that she felt for the artist and his work… The attempt to justify this one way act of love by its artistic nature should just as well fail. Holding this fleeting kiss only as a violation of respect for the work, the appellate judges considered, as the lower court had, that the incrimination of vandalism, such as covered by articles L 322-1 of the Penal Code, was required.

Therefore, artistic passion is not a valid defense and unshared love has got a price. We know now how much it costs.

Jessica Giraud

Comments

subscribe to comments RSS feed
#0001alain cartier said | 25/03/2010 12:14
Ca ne coute pas € 18,840 euros pour effacer le rouge a levre d'une femme sur une toile peinte a l'huile !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
En aucun cas le rouge a levre a endommagé la peinture !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
#0002Antoine said | 13/09/2010 00:46
Effectivement, on ne comprend pas bien la décision du juge...

leave a comment


Tribunal de Grande Instance de Paris, 20 mai 2011, Syndicat National des Antiquaires c/ Christie’s

Contrefaçon ou contre pub ?

« Our body / A corps ouvert », accord perdu !

LA PLACE DES RESTES HUMAINS DANS LE DOMAINE PUBLIC CULTUREL

Quand la Lady rend son producteur Gaga

Google écrit une page jurisprudentielle

Quand agir permet de détenir

ArtyParade ©

Un Arrêt de la Cour de Cassation rappelle l’importance des « catalogues raisonnés »

Le chaos mis en demeure

A very bling bling kiss

Ideas are free to travel, not the works of art which formalize them

VIPs but not original

Exhibit towards and against the artist: Yes we can

The story of a title …